It’s Twilight Time.
Posted in Books, Movies, Time 2 Piss People Off on November 26th, 2008 by sherlockI saw the movie Twilight this weekend and I finished reading the book last night so this will be a review of both. I’ll give a short review of the movie and then the book and then talk in general about both. This will contain spoilers so you’ve been warned.
The movie was about what I thought, it was a chick flick and not really something I enjoy. The first 5 hours were a little slow, dealing mostly with the love story of Bella and Edward who turns out to be a vampire. Edward and his family don’t drink human blood so in a way they are good(?) vampires. The love story gets interrupted by a 20 second scene where the bad vampires show up and we don’t see them attack a human. Later on we see them playing baseball and the bad vamps show up and one wants to eat Bella and then there’s a 5 minute action scene that involves edward and the bad vamp pushing each other into walls a few times and then the bad vamp is killed off screen. the next hour is then a setup for the sequel. I’ll give it 3 puke buckets!
Ok now the book, It’s the same story, except the bad vamps don’t attack the human, we don’t get to them until the baseball game. The love story drags on for 15 chapters before we get into anything else, the next 2 chapters at least we get some history on the family and on Carlyle, the ‘father’ of the group. We finally get to the bad vamps and the hunt is on. I thought this at least was handled better in the book and it seemed at least a little longer and more involved, but once again what happens to the bad vamp is off screen so to speak. The writing was OK I guess, not great but not bad either. Being generous, I would say it was 3 stars.
Now for more observations, this will be for both the film and book, but mostly the book. As I was reading this some things just bugged me, I had to look up the publication date but it was written in 2004 and published in 2005. I thought that maybe the author was an older writer but then I saw her on a movie preview show and that wasn’t the case, she was fairly young, in her thirties. In this day and age, it really bugged me that NO ONE HAD A CELL PHONE! I would say that maybe they didn’t have reception in Forks (the town they were in) except for the fact that late in the book when the are running from the hunter, Carlyle gives them one! These are teenaged girls, in 2005 most would have had cellphones, and a cop surely would have. I was late getting a phone and I had one in ’05. Bella’s mom was worried about her and would freak when anything happened to Bella, don’t you think a cellphone would be a requirement, especially since her mom travelled a lot?
What about iPods? in the movie Bella does have an iPod, but the book had her listening to a CD player. This one I would be willing to let pass even though iPods hit big in ’03, but then in Edward’s room that is full of high tech gear and hundreds of records and CDs, he doesn’t have an iPod?
Bella was in high school and was friends with girls there, there is no way she would be able to forget when the prom is, that is just the dumbest thing I have ever read. You might get me to believe that she didn’t know that was where Edward was taking her, but not that she didn’t know that it was that night. Don’t you think her friends would be talking non stop about it for weeks before? No way, this I call BS. I also find it hard to believe that Taylor would not make sure he was the one taking her, that was just silly.
Edward and family went to high school, why? They lived in a small town, they could probably get away with telling people they were home schooled or something. I know they said it was so they could stay longer, but I’m not sure on that but we’ll let that go. When I was in school, I missed a lot of days because of illness, so I know that at least back then, they only gave you a certain amount of days you could miss before you were failed, a doctors note was required for more then that. Ed and family missed a lot of days as shown in the book. Yes, I know what you are thinking, Carlyle was a doctor and could give them the excuse they needed right? Not really, first off, it didn’t seem like it was a secret that they were not sick, they were off ‘hiking’. Maybe the school didn’t mind? Doesn’t matter, the school would have to have records that go to the county and state, someone is bound to notice all the absences and wonder why the whole family seemed to get sick at the same time and the doctors notes were signed by the father! This might just shorten the time they can spend in a town, and not all towns would be accommodating.
Bella thinks that Ed is a vampire and decides to confront him the next day at school. She waits for him outside the school sitting on a bench enjoying the first sunny day since she got to forks, she is surprised and mad that he isn’t at school. The next day is the same, she waits outside in the sun for Edward the vampire and he doesn’t show, she is once again surprised. I wonder why he didn’t show?
Now for the one thing that really bugged me… Beautiful Edward. No, I had no problem with the character of Edward, It was beautiful Edward or gorgeous Edward or stunning…. WTF? She doesn’t write Edward without beautiful or a synonym of beautiful in front of it. OK I get it, he was good looking. It is so bad that I think I could safely bet that the word beautiful or a synonym of it is on every page from the moment the he appears. If you were to remove beautiful and it’s synonyms from the book it would be maybe two chapters. By the end of the book I wanted to fly to Arizona or where ever this Meyer chick lives and punch her in the face for every fucking ‘beautiful’ that is in the book! I’m not sure I could stomach the next book if it is the same!
I’m sure I could continue, but the post is getting long so I’ll end it here. I do want to post more about the Twilight series, but a more serious discussion so I’ll see about that another day.











